Should a pastor evaluate his ministry by numbers?

There is an epidemic in the American Church.  It is an obsession with basing fruitfulness in ministry on a numbers game.   The American way is bigger and better and I am troubled that the church in many ways has bought into this method of evaluation, and continues to do so.  I would hope that all pastors want more people to come hear the gospel preached, experience the warm fellowship of our people, be baptized, discipled, and flourish in the church.  If you do not desire these things, please do not be a pastor.  Yet, in my experience of serving on staff at two different mega churches, closely knowing many other churches, and observing the envy that some small churches possess towards larger churches, there is a great deal focus on numbers as that which deems a ministry fruitful and faithful.

There are several problems with a pastor allowing numbers to be the measuring stick of our ministries, but here is the greatest:  It does not appear to be how God evaluates our ministries.  According to Hebrews 13:17, God is evaluating our ministries based on our faithfulness to “care for souls as those who will give an account.”  Numbers may communicate all kinds of good things about one’s ministry, but whether God is pleased with it based on numbers is a dangerous conclusion to make.  Especially if the Chief Shepherd will hold a pastor to account for all those “reached” and brought into the church…but whose souls are neglected.

For pastors who are feeling the pressure of this number’s measuring stick, there is some helpful counsel for you.  However, I had to seek it from outside the American Church scene and from a different time altogether.  The 19th century Scottish pastor and trainer of pastors, John Brown, wrote a letter to one of his students newly ordained over a small congregation and extended this word to him:

 I know the vanity of your heart, and that you will feel mortified that your congregation is very small, in comparison with those of your brethren around you; but assure yourself on the word of an old man, that when you come to give an account of them to the Lord Christ at his judgment seat, you will think you have had enough. 

Pastors, regardless the pressures you face in your congregation to “produce the numbers”  focus on caring for souls.  Be faithful to evangelize, preach the gospel every week, pray for conversions, but make sure your primary focus is on caring for souls.  When we stand before God to give an account for the souls of our flock, God will not be impressed with our increased numbers, but how faithful we cared for the souls of those that make up that number.

Posted in Oversight of Souls, The Pastor's Soul
4 comments on “Should a pastor evaluate his ministry by numbers?
  1. Allen Mickle says:

    How about when your numbers continue to dwindle and now you shepherd a church of 25 people? Isn’t then there any sense where the numbers game might be an indication of blessing or problem?

    • briancroft says:

      Sure, Allen. Good point. Depending upon the issue, a dip in numbers could indicate a move in a healthy direction. But, it can be a problem for many reasons also, especially if people are leaving from an unfaithfulness from the pastor and a neglect of their souls. I think it is a case by case issue. Numbers do reveal some indicators, but is not the sole measure of faithfulness. Thanks for the clarification!

  2. When I look at the few sheep in the wilderness that i have been given to oversee, it seems insignificant when comparing it with the mega churches. But when you get involved in the lives of each individual and you realize how much spiritual growth has to be made in them, a congregation of as little as ten would seem overwhelming!

    • Allen Mickle says:

      I think what I meant was, our church was larger and is continuing to shrink. I’m personally concerned that the evidence of this shrinking is a reflection of an issue in my leadership. So, my point, is that low numbers may be an indication of an issue, which in my case, I believe may be the point.

3 Pings/Trackbacks for "Should a pastor evaluate his ministry by numbers?"
  1. […] & success: * Should a Pastor Evaluate His Ministry by Numbers? by Brian Croft * It’s All About the Numbers: Changing How We Measure Success in the Church by […]

  2. […] Share this:TwitterFacebookEmailPrintDiggLinkedInStumbleUponRedditLike this:LikeBe the first to like this post. […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *



Help send free Practical Shepherding resources to pastors around the world.



RSS Feeds: