Ep. 317: Doctrinal differences with a pastor and church
In this episode, Brian Croft and Jim Savastio offer a deeply pastoral roadmap for handling ministry and theological differences without blowing up a congregation. They unpack key biblical texts, the importance of building trust through careful exegesis and personal care, and how to navigate seasons when your own convictions change over time. If you’re pastoring an existing church—or hope to—this conversation will steady your heart and sharpen your approach.
Contact us. We’d love to serve you
Request a stay at a Shepherd’s House Location
Give financially to support the work of helping pastors thrive
Write a review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify Resources
(01:57) Biblical Framework for Handling Differences
(03:52) The Tension: Bold Preaching with Great Patience
(04:21) Scenario 1 – Entering an Established Church with Different Views
(06:45) Text-Driven, Book-by-Book Approach
(11:27) Strategy for Early Years in a Church
(14:21) Avoiding Buzzwords & Building Collateral
(16:50) The Role of Personal Pastoral Care
(17:34) Aim Is Not Total Theological Uniformity
(18:49) What If You Haven’t Yet Gained Trust?
(22:42) Scenario 2 – When a Pastor Changes His Own Position
(23:58) Role of Confessions and Statements of Faith
(27:05) Case Study: Statement of Faith and the Sabbath
(29:40) Interviewing and Fit: Don’t Assume You’ll “Change It Later”
(31:12) Preaching with a Clean Conscience
(32:50) A Real-World Example of Pastoral Patience in Change
(34:09) Final Word and Prayer