Ep. 329: Preaching to the tender conscience
This Trench Talk episode explores how pastors can preach to tender consciences without abandoning strong, biblical exhortation. Brian Croft and Jim Savastio trace the trend toward harsh, “hammer” preaching, reflect on their own overreactions, and emphasize knowing the flock, balancing law and gospel, maintaining hope, and patiently trusting the Spirit—aiming to be both faithful and effective in pastoral ministry.
Contact us. We’d love to serve you
Request a stay at a Shepherd’s House Location
Give financially to support the work of helping pastors thrive
Write a review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify
Purchase tickets for the Advancing the Church Equip Conference taking place September 10-11, 2026 in New Albany, IN.
Find our newest book release, Pastor, what are you wearing? Learning the Unspoken, Powerful Message of Attire by Kyle McClellan here.
(03:32) Setting up the Topic: Good Shepherd, bruised reed, and advocate (John 10; Matt 12; 1 John 2)
(06:21) 2 Timothy 4:2 – strong exhortation joined with great patience and teaching
(07:52) Why harsh, “hammer” preaching is celebrated (reaction to church-growth / soft preaching)
(12:37) Croft’s overreaction to weak preaching and a friend’s “you need to chill” correction
(16:15) Faithful and effective: fear of man, law-only vs. comfort-only ministry
(20:10) How to preach to tender consciences: wounding and then binding up
(22:56) Knowing your flock: medicine vs. poison and dangers of one-tone preaching
(24:55) Keeping sermons hopeful; translating private care of sensitive souls into public preaching
(28:23) Law–gospel tension and the exhausting pursuit of doing “enough”
(32:00) Grace, obedience, assurance, and pride in the tender conscience
(33:05) Final exhortations: patience, prayer, and accepting we cannot fix people